The Bubble of Climate Change Groupthink Burst By a Cooling World

Recently, I’ve taken to reading ‘Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds,’ a highly-regarded history of popular folly by Scottish journalist Charles Mackay, first published in 1841. His work can teach us a timely lesson in the current global warming controversy.


MacKay warns us of the pitfalls of group think using many notable historical examples when people,


 “fix their minds upon one object, and go mad in its pursuit; that millions of people become simultaneously impressed with one delusion, and run after it, till their attention is caught by some new folly more captivating than the first.”


The wise Scot goes on to cite many notable examples but one case struck me as I remembered it from my school days from the not so merry England of the 18th century. A total of 462 members of the House of Commons and 112 Peers signed up to the South Sea Company that persuaded vast swathes of the general public to also get sucked into one of the greatest financial scandals in history, the ‘South Sea Bubble.’

Even King George I and two of his mistresses, the Countess of Darlington and the Duchess of Kendal, got taken in and lost a fortune while countless citizens went bankrupt in the ill-founded venture. Thus we see how the ‘great and the good’ can unwittingly lead us all into disaster.


Now welcome to the transmografied world of our modern ‘bubble’ where the ‘great and the good’ have again apparently been undone by a groupthink calamity over climate change in which our perceptions have starkly changed almost overnight. From being fearful of so called man made warming it seems the real danger is from cooling. It turns out that since January 2007, the world has cooled so rapidly that ALL the global warming over the past three decades has disappeared!


The cold facts are confirmed by a plot of actual global average temperatures from the best available source, weather satellite data that shows there has been NO net global warming since the satellites were first launched in 1979. Thus the argument that carbon dioxide emitted by western society that was thought to warm the atmosphere is doing no such thing. See larger image


 Today’s bubble burst when the Climategate revelations exposed a government-funded clique of scientists as utter polemicists, sophists and necromancers. Leaked emails  from this scandal show scientists puzzled by highly-compelling temperature data proving the world is more likely to now be cooling rather than warming contrary to scientific expectations. Rather than make this finding public it was hushed up – until now. We are thus confronted by confusion in a backdrop of the worst economic recession for 60 years and wher tax a weary public have grown thoroughly sick of being nagged by nanny governments to cut our carbon footprint.


The facts expose the pointlessness of expending any more hot air over what an increasing number of commentators are calling a non-problem since Britain’s most eminent government climate scientist, Professor Phil Jones admitted the planet has seen no statistically significant warming for over 15 years! Just as in the days of King George I, we see the hubris of ‘experts’ and politicians leaving behind them a profligate money trail exposing their gullibility to the dangers and the myth of consensus- it was all just a climate chimera.


Independent analysis of real world data are now urging us to re-think once more the threat of cooling as we are in the midst of a cooling period to match the one we saw from 1940-75, as reported in Readers’ Digest (March 1977) ‘

What’s Happening To Our Climate?’ The there was the Newsweek article of April 28 1975 that warned us of ‘The Cooling World.



But far more weight should be given to the CIA report that proved government concern over global cooling in the 1970’s and the impact on world politics. Amongst the host of references is Hubert Lamb – the first Director of CRU- Lamb writes in his many books of the climatic downturns which started sometime aroud 1960. So this brings us back neatly to the words of Charles Mackay and the example of the ‘South Sea Bubble’ scandal that taught us:


"Men, it has been well said, think in herds; it will be seen that they go mad in herds, while they only recover their senses slowly, and one by one."


Let there be no doubt, the next new paradigm may well be that the warming blip from 1975-195 that global warmists get so hot about may be seen to be an anamoly in the global cooling that can be said to have affected the planet since the

Medieval Warm Period ended in the 1300’s. This is a most credible hypothesis being that we are due to return to an ice age anyway.


But the biggest paradigm shift now taking place is the abandonment of the hypothesis that CO2 was a significant driver of planetary warming. The facts prove that  the Earth’s temperature record shows global cooling from ~1940 to ~1979 and this coupled with recent sharp cooling proves that overall, there has been no net warming since ~1940, in spite of an ~800% increase in human emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2). Thus the correlation between temperature rises and CO2 is bust so that the recent warming trend was probably entirely natural. Therefore, the CO2 bubble has now popped!









Filed under Uncategorized

4 responses to “The Bubble of Climate Change Groupthink Burst By a Cooling World

  1. Big Scary Predictions that have yet to Come True
    John – another excellent piece. The analogy with the South Sea Bubble is telling, but perhaps not the best, since all involved were in it to enrich theselves, whereas the bulk of climate alarmists pride themselves on their willingness to do the opposite.
    If you haven’t already seen it, have a look at Kesten Green’s structural analysis of analogous catastrophe scares over the last century and a half, up to and including AGW, but embracing such corkers as Eugenics, Y2K and Al Gore’s earlier folly, the demonisation of DDT, and a delightfully obscure mid-nineteenth century alarm over supposedly exhausted supplies of spar timber for ships.
    Importantly, he studies the effects of public policy “responses” to his scares, finding costly, growth-inhibiting, pointless and redundant legislation on statute books decades after the scare itself has been forgotten – presumably because repeal would require too many people to repudiate explicitly theories they earlier held to be “settled science”.
    This is the real reason why people like you need to keep up the heat – seeing the alarmists twist on the gibbet is incidental compensation.

    • Re: Big Scary Predictions that have yet to Come True
      Tom, thanks for the excellent tip. I am looking into your suggestions now and I shall certainly be amending the article to include your fine examples.
      All the best,

  2. Существует ли ответ, что происходит с экосистемой планеты?
    Происходит глобальное потепление или похолодание? Какие факторы могут влиять на этот процесс и как изменить климат в положительную для Человека сторону?
    Что происходит с пустынями,засухами,снегопадами, сильными дождями в отдельных регионах, ледниками, атмосферой,течениями?Каков механизм образования гигантских волн в океане?Каков механизм образования торнадо,смерчей,потоков воздуха? Как повлиять на происходящие процессы?
    От каких факторов зависит погода и как управлять погодой?
    Почему официальная наука не может дать однозначный ответ о прошлом и даже ближайшем будущем?
    Is there an answer, what happens to the ecosystem of the planet?
    Going global warming or cooling? What factors can influence this process and how to change the climate in a positive direction for Man?
    What happens to the deserts, drought, snow, heavy rains in some regions, glaciers, atmosphere, currents? What is the mechanism for the formation of giant waves in the ocean? What is the mechanism of formation of a tornado, tornadoes, the air flow? How to influence the processes?
    What factors depends on the weather and how to control the weather?
    Why is the official science can not give a definite answer about the past and even the near future?

  3. Перспективная экономика, энергосберегающие управленческие системы, новые технологии управления,решение проблемы глобального потепления, как регулировать климат,экология,история,философия,право,аналитика,наука.
    Аналитика “полного цикла” с коррекцией объекта управления;
    стратегическая и тактическая системная аналитика и прогноз;
    управление проектами;
    консультационное обеспечение создания производства и сопровождение его деятельности;
    консультации по созданию бизнеса в финансовом секторе экономики и сопровождение его деятельности;
    правовая экспертиза документов и коммерческих схем;
    корпоративное право и антикризисное управление,банковское право, консультации по залогу и ипотеке, взаимоотношениям Клиента и Банка при возникновении проблемных вопросов, исполнительному производству.
    Perspective economics, energy management systems, new technology management, solutions to global warming (decision of problem of global rise in temperature), how to regulate the climate, ecology, history, philosophy, law, analytics, science, economy,economic perspectives.
    Interested in business contacts, get acquainted with their colleagues on their interests.
    -Optimization of the organizations, enterprises, commercial structures and institutions;
    -analysis charts of activity, recommendation;
    -analytics to order;
    -multilevel marketing;
    -how to make the correct decisions – the theory and methodology;
    -legal consultations.
    Service in Ukraine.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s